For October 16, 2007...
As the discussion thread on the Society for Technical Communication's mailing list recently concluded:
"I'd rather have a sharp object inserted into my eye than deal with Second Life or a similar virtual world."
There are several reasons for this:
I like threaded discussions and have used them for several years as a teacher. However, interactive chats have ended up dominated by the same students who speak up during a traditional class session. I find asynchronous threads give more students a chance to participate.
Blog post: Add a YackPack plugin to your PBwiki (click on plug-ins) and try it out. Sign-up for tappedin.org (http://ti2.sri.com/tappedin/index.jsp) and explore its features for online chat (see how it was used at Hillcrest High School:I gave up trying plug-ins with OS X and Safari, which I think might happen in many educational settings. I just don't have the energy to manually link and setup so many items, even though I have done so with images and other elements in PBwki. As with Google Docs and other "Web 2.0" items not supporting Apple's browser at this time, I generally won't sacrifice my system to another browser. (FireFox is the only major alternative, though Camino is also a Mozilla application.)
http://www.slideshare.net/sbgaddy/hillcrest-high-school-21st-century-project-student-products). Reflect on how you might use tappenin.org or other discussion sites (WebCT/Vista, Moodle, Drupal) or tools (IM’ing, etc.) or virtual/game sites (Second City, etc.) for online discussion.
As the discussion thread on the Society for Technical Communication's mailing list recently concluded:
"I'd rather have a sharp object inserted into my eye than deal with Second Life or a similar virtual world."
There are several reasons for this:
- The animation is poor without a very powerful computer, and even then it seems to demand a lot of resources.
- The movement can cause problems for some users, especially those with seizure disorders or migraines.
- Most virtual worlds, for whatever reason, end up with the same social issues as "real life," with a bit more flirting and a lot more anger.
- I hate most live chats, with or without animation, because I read slowly. Unless it is one-on-one, I get lost quickly.
I like threaded discussions and have used them for several years as a teacher. However, interactive chats have ended up dominated by the same students who speak up during a traditional class session. I find asynchronous threads give more students a chance to participate.
Comments
Post a Comment