Skip to main content

Kindle so-so for students, UW study concludes

Brier Dudley's Blog | Kindle so-so for students, UW study concludes | Seattle Times Newspaper
Seven months into the study, more than 60 percent of the students had stopped using their Kindle regularly for academic reading -- and these were computer science students, who are presumably more sympathetic to an electronic book.
I'm not surprised that an eReader doesn't replace books. Taking notes and highlighting are part of the reading process that a Kindle or other eReader doesn't easily replicate.

I recall what a page looks like, from the graphics to the pattern of paragraphs. On an eReader, I can't always locate where a bit of information is. You can't say it is on "Page X" because the pagination changes with font size and other choices a user can change.

Many of us would like to imagine eReaders catching on with universities because textbooks are so expensive. The prices of textbooks are outrageous: my last course text was $100 for students and could not be resold because it was customized by the university. If a student pays $100 or more per course, that's at least $800 to $1000 a year for books. An eReader is $300 or less, such as the Color Nook or Kindle DX.

The problem is, students don't find the eReader a convenient experience. If six of ten stop using it, there is definitely a problem. I'd also wonder how well students recall what they read on screen. I know I tend to skim when I read an eBook. I don't pause and go back to reread as I do with a printed page.

Taking notes? Forget it. I use paper because I remember what I write more than what I type. Plus, typing on a Kindle (small keyboard) or Nook (touchscreen) is awkward. I have seen students taking notes on an iPad, but I would probably purchase a small keyboard for something like the iPad.

Maybe the worst reason an eReader won't replace textbooks? The publishers didn't offer a substantial discount! You end up paying as much for many books as you might in print. Students save money buying used texts when compared to a Kindle and new eBooks.

Some publishers promise students will "rent" books in the future. The problem with that? I already see the local college bookstore offers a form of rental. What's the benefit to renting the eBook? It still costs more than "renting" the print edition.

I do love eBooks. Why?

  1. I have learned I can highlight, copy, and paste right into my academic papers. That beats retyping passages and making mistakes. 
  2. The books are convenient, when compared to having stacks of books on my desk. 
  3. I can read in bed without a nightlight. My wife appreciates that.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

More Than a Typewriter: The Power of Word

Visalia Direct: Virtual Valley March 3, 2014 Deadline April 2014 Issue More Than a Typewriter: The Power of Word Typewriters still amaze me, especially the antique mechanical models. There’s something wonderful about the feel of levers, gears, springs and rollers working together to transmit thoughts into words. Typewriters possess a romance computer keyboards and touch screens lack. But, please, stop using your word processor like a typewriter. Word processor abuse mars many otherwise good documents. Bad habits people develop over time lead to documents that are ugly and difficult to edit and revise. The numerous excuses for improper word processing deserve dismissal. It does not take days or even hours to learn to use tabs effectively. Paragraph styles take minutes to understand and appreciate. Even a complex looking table of contents takes only a few mouse clicks to create if you construct a document properly. When you know more about your software tools, you also kno...

eCheating: Students using high-tech tricks – USATODAY.com

This fall, I resorted to using "anti-plagairism" tools for the first time in at least six years. One reason for this is that what I had been teaching at the University of Minnesota didn't lend itself to plagiarism. My technical writing students had to design a new toy or board game, create a prototype, and develop a product pitch. It's hard to steal another person's LEGO project that uses randomly selected bricks. However, teaching a literature class I found that students either had problems with understanding citation norms or they simply assumed an instructor wouldn't check to determine if a passage was a copy-paste effort. I learned this is a great reason to have two mandatory drafts before a final paper, too. My department head and other colleagues were supportive and I'm now working on a reusable lesson module that will address citations. Student don't quite grasp that simply because you can copy-paste doesn't mean it is acceptable. ...

Word Macro for Word Abusers

I overuse some words and phrases in my writing. Most writers have some problem words. It isn't that the words should never be used, or that we use them incorrectly. We simply use them too frequently. The following Microsoft Word VBA macro marks words I should check for overuse. Also included are words and phrases I should avoid. Feel free to copy and modify this macro. I encourage my students to try this macro, too. Once you have the macro in Word, you can alter the word list to reflect your preferences and habits. Sub macWordsToAvoid() Dim vFindText As Variant Dim txtWord As Variant 'list the exceptions to look for in an array vFindText = Array("about", "all", "almost", "a lot", "already", "always", "along with", _ "anxiously", "absolutely", "as well", "believe", "certainly", "clearly", "definitely", _ "eagerly",...